You're viewing a single post. I have much more to say! The main blog page is a good starting point.

Gnome ChangeLog policy

Saturday, December 30, 2006 ★ 21:12 ★ Category Gnome

Now that Gnome is about to use Subversion for all its source code repositories, it might be worth rethinking the current ChangeLog policy. The situation until now (CVS) is like this:

Add an entry to ChangeLog before committing. This can be done by hand or scripted using prepare-ChangeLog (which also finds out which C functions were affected; pretty useful information).

Issue cvs commit ChangeLog file.[ch] and duplicate the ChangeLog entry as the commit message. You can use copy/paste; I use a Vim buffer myself. This can also be done with some shell scripting using cvs commit -m "`head -n10 ChangeLog`", but it requires some testing to get the number of lines correct.
However, since Subversion supports proper changesets (instead of per-file revisions), the commit message serves exactly the same purpose as the ChangeLog entry, namely the recording of per-commit change messages (instead of per-file). This means it isn’t necessary anymore to duplicate the commit message, which is a tedious and time-consuming job.

So my question is: should we change the ChangeLog policy now that we have a SCM that allows us poor developers to do The Right Thing? Some issues I’ve come up with so far:

Offline logs: This issue was brought up earlier several times, eg. on the Subversion users mailing list and the Mono mailing list. Some ideas:
Perhaps Subversion can be taught somehow to keep a copy of the logs in the local checkout as well, in addition to pristine copies of all files in the repository?
Perhaps some svk based solution?

Perhaps bzr-svn once it matures a bit?
Inclusion in tarballs: ChangeLog files can easily be included in tarball releases. No magic needed. This issue can be resolved quite easily with the simple Makefile.am snippet below (passes distcheck). I use it succesfully for my bzr-managed gnome-specimen project.
```
EXTRA_DIST += ChangeLog
dist-hook:
        svn log -v > ChangeLog.new
        mv -f ChangeLog.new $(distdir)/ChangeLog
```
Using svn2cl is probably better, but since I have no experience using it I have just changed this above snippet to use svn log -v instead of bzr log --short.

Random photo from Paris (January, 2007)

Who wrote all this?

Wouter Bolsterlee, also known as uws, a postmodern geek living in the Netherlands. Read more about me…

Stay informed

RSS 2.0 feed

On Planet Gnome

On Planet Gnome-NL

Blog archives

Copyright

Unless stated otherwise, all material on this site is available under a Creative Commons Share-Alike license.